Cottage in Cayuga Lake, NY
4 guests · 1 bedroom · 1 bath
Reasons to book
Guests love it hereGuests give this property a top rating
Great for petsBring all your friends and family, even the furry ones
Well priced for this locationPriced under area average
About this cottage rental
A quiet, quaint lakefront cottage located 2 miles in on a private dirt road, great for walking or bike rides. Cottage is on the east side of the lake, close to Aurora, and several wineries and restaurants.
This is our vacation paradise. When we are not enjoying it with family and friends we rent it out. We don’t treat it as a rental. It has the quirkiness that comes from being our cottage. We are always changing, adding, updating. Our very first renter still comes back every year and looks for what we changed or added. Our cottage has over 200 feet of level beachfront, small dock, and is on a more secluded part of Cayuga lake. On the east shore so there are amazing sunsets. The cottage itself has one large camp style bedroom with one double bed and a twin over full bunk bed. Has a living/dining room, fully equipped kitchen, and bathroom with shower. The outside features a large wraparound covered porch with lots of seating, and amazing views. There is also a sun deck, and BBQ area. Note: There is no tv, or internet. If you are looking for a quiet place to get away from it all and unwind this is it!!!
Amenities at Rustic lakefront cottage
Non-smoking
Pets allowed
Family friendly
Map of Cayuga Lake, NY
Ratings and reviews
Summary of reviewsGuests loved the quiet, beautiful views, well-appointed spaces, and kind host. They enjoyed the relaxation by the lake, spacious property, and peaceful atmosphere. The property was clean, well-furnished, and had great cooking options.
10 / 10Outstanding·Sep 2025
Over All very peaceful,, quiet and enjoying
10 / 10Outstanding·Aug 2025
We had a great time unplugging at the lake. Brad was super helpful with ideas of things to do and places to grab things we may have forgotten. It is so quiet there, minus the waves on the rocky beach. We loved howmany outside areas there are to use- there is always shade or sun somewhere! The kitchen had everything we needed, and was easy to use because of the map they left! We’d definitely stay here again!
10 / 10Outstanding·Aug 2025
Enjoyed the peaceful beachfront cottage. Just right for a quiet getaway. The host was very good about letting us know what to expect and gave us some great ideas for area eateries. Would go back again!
6 / 10Average·Sep 2024
Brad was so personable and great on the details and plenty of stocked items . To write the following things trouble me because Brad was So Great. Friday evening Brad even reached out to let us know how to turn the heat on because he knew the temps were going to drop. My number one issue … I’ve never arrived at a rental that was so filthy. Surfaces were not clean. Coffee pot caked with old coffee . Anything you pulled from the drawers had to be washed first. Floors so dirty . In great need of being swept and scrubbed , covered in dog hair. First five minutes of our arrival the overwhelming smell was sour dish sponges . Later that night when my niece went to bed there were shorts and underwear on the floor around her bed. The second smell was found today which was a dead mouse and millipede . I appreciated being able to travel with my senior dog but got concerned when I saw the mouse. I started wondering if there was poison left out that I wasn’t aware of. The place itself if all concerns didn’t exist is a wonderful location with a very pleasant neighborhood. .Brad has it decorated so well and the outside says come , relax and enjoy.
$$$$
Top rated by guests
9.8Outstanding
(37 Ratings)
Guests loved the quiet, beautiful views, well-appointed spaces, and kind host. They enjoyed the relaxation by the lake, spacious property, and peaceful atmosphere. The property was clean, well-furnished, and had great cooking options.
From real guest reviews summarized by AIDon't miss out! Price and availability may change
