South Street Cottage: Bright & Sunny with Pool, Patio & Hot Tub

Our new home away from home! Everything was above and beyond exceptional! Cant wait to go back! Had everything we needed- fully stocked! Super clean. Private. Comfortable. 5 stars all around. Thank yall

Rating Details: The property manager was very helpful. The vacation rental was very clean. I was very happy with the location. I was very satisfied with the condition of the vacation rental. Overall, I recommend this vacation rental. Reviewer Comments: South St Cottage was one of our best rentals ever, and we rent a lot! It was by far the best-stocked home as far as kitchenware, supplies, etc. They thought of EVERYTHING, and it was all very nice quality, not just cheap "rental" items. We were so impressed. The pool is wonderful, the beds were comfortable, plenty of space for parking, a great location...everything we needed. And a fabulous new waterfall rain shower in the primary bath! Extensive artwork collection, too. Again, very nice things as if it were the owner's home and not just a rental. The only cons were that the floors were rather dirty upon arrival, almost as if the cleaning crew had missed them somehow. Also, the deck by the pool had several sections that are a little rotted out and for children or elderly folks could pose a hazard to walk on. We noted the owners have a building permit posted out front where it appears they intend to repair the decking. We discovered, entirely by chance, a drawer at one end of the kitchen/dining table that has a cornucopia of pamphlets, coupons, and other great info about Key West attractions and restaurants—renters should be notified about this treasure so they can benefit from all the good info. So, all in all, would absolutely recommend this cottage to anyone wanting a great, quiet, and well-located stay in KW!

Rating Details: The property manager was very helpful. The vacation rental was very clean. I was very happy with the location. I was very satisfied with the condition of the vacation rental. Overall, I recommend this vacation rental. Reviewer Comments: South St Cottage was one of our best rentals ever, and we rent a lot! It was by far the best-stocked home as far as kitchenware, supplies, etc. They thought of EVERYTHING, and it was all very nice quality, not just cheap "rental" items. We were so impressed. The pool is wonderful, the beds were comfortable, plenty of space for parking, a great location...everything we needed. And a fabulous new waterfall rain shower in the primary bath! Extensive artwork collection, too. Again, very nice things as if it were the owner's home and not just a rental. The only cons were that the floors were rather dirty upon arrival, almost as if the cleaning crew had missed them somehow. Also, the deck by the pool had several sections that are a little rotted out and for children or elderly folks could pose a hazard to walk on. We noted the owners have a building permit posted out front where it appears they intend to repair the decking. We discovered, entirely by chance, a drawer at one end of the kitchen/dining table that has a cornucopia of pamphlets, coupons, and other great info about Key West attractions and restaurants—renters should be notified about this treasure so they can benefit from all the good info. So, all in all, would absolutely recommend this cottage to anyone wanting a great, quiet, and well-located stay in KW!

Rating Details: The property manager was very unhelpful. The vacation rental was very dirty. I was happy with the location. I was very dissatisfied with the condition of the vacation rental. Overall, I do not recommend this vacation rental. Reviewer Comments: The outdoor space and pool is fabulous. The weekly pool man did a wonderful job.....But, the house was dirty (moldings hadn't been washed or dusted for at least a year, some dishes had mold on them, and the toilet was barely wiped clean to name just a few of the cleaning issues) and much needed fixing (the dishwasher was falling out of the cabinet and flooded the entire kitchen floor the first time we used it ~ the towels were filthy when I wiped all that water off the floor/ didn't plan on washing floors on my vacation!), the air conditioner did not work in the second bedroom and was probably the reason there was black mold behind the bed and nightstand, the front gate lock wasn't keeping anyone out because it was falling off, the towel bar on the sliding glass shower door fell off in my hands, and there was a large hole in the living room wall from someone pushing a couch too hard into the wall.) Overall, it seems as though nothing has been done to this house in years! When I called Rent Key West the first day and reported all of this they wanted to send people out to address my long list, but I was on vacation and didn't want to entertain a bevy of work people coming and going. They did quickly send someone to fix the dishwasher and replace the gas tank for the grill (which no longer lit automatically. We had to go buy a lighter to get it started). Lastly, we stopped in to see the rental agent and when her bulldog came from out of nowhere and attacked our 12 lb dog, I fell on my back during the rukus. A decent, caring person would have called the next day to see how I was. Nope, never heard from her. Before her dog caming running out she was blaming the management company for the poor condition of the house, isn't that them?? This rental agency has lost our business. We have rented a far more expensive house for three months in Key West for next winter, but not this house or with this rental agency.