Charming updated home with pool on quiet street. Near Silver Beach

This was a “home away from homes” as it was such a clean and family friendly home with such a good eye for beach-chic decor and colors and every amenity needed to have a solid family vacay week. The pool was perfection, the neighborhood was quiet with wide streets and little traffic… many runs from the house to Shell Beach and down to the beautiful views along Crescent Beach. Enjoyed the local farmers market at Sylvester Manor and many restaurants. Host, Paul, was easy to communicate and very accommodating. We will definitely return for another Shelter Island getaway. And if we could give ten stars, we certainly would.

It was simply amazing. The property was clean. The owner was very responsive we needed something. They left us all the necessary information to get around in shelter island.

We had a great stay on Shelter Island. Paul was a responsive host. The house was well equipped with everything we needed - from basic items like extra garbage bags etc to bikes and beach toys. It meant the week was hassle free and we could enjoy the house and Shelter Island. The pool was lovely and got sun all day. The property was equipped with alarms on the doors to the pool area which gave us peace of mind traveling with young children. We would stay again!

We had a great time staying at Paul’s house. The pool was great and the house had all that we needed for a fun two weeks vacation. Paul was generous, responsive and helpful. The house and that area of Shelter island is wonderful location. I would 100% recommend this property.