House in Menemsha, MA
8 guests · 5 bedrooms · 2 baths
Reasons to book
Guests love it hereGuests give this property a top rating
High-end valueWell priced for this area
Book with confidenceWe partner with the top travel sites so you know you're getting a great deal on the perfect rental
About this house rental
"Chilmark is quiet, laid back and much less congested than down-island counterparts. If you want to spread out and relax, this is an excellent part of the Island to visit. Alley's General Store and the Chilmark Tavern are nearby if you need provisions or a nice dinner. The rental itself is set back, very private, and has a massive grass yard for kids to play in. A great stay!"
-Alison, guest, May 2018
Thanks Alison. Here's more:
Bright and open Chilmark split-level home perfect for your next family vacation. FULLY AIR CONDITIONED. New refrigerator and commercial washing machine perfect for long stays. Fresh exterior paint and newly rebuilt wrap-around deck. Some interior upgrades expected by spring 2025. Wrap-around deck perfect for early morning reading, evening cocktails or star-gazing. Close to Alley's General Store, West Tisbury Farmer's Market, hiking trails and bike paths. Guests may purchase guest passes to Lucy Vincent Beach through Town of Chilmark. Walking access to nearby private Chilmark beach. Ten minute drive to Menemsha sunsets and lobsters or juicy whole belly fried clams at the Fish House in Edgartown-best take-out option for quick up-island dinners.
-Alison, guest, May 2018
Thanks Alison. Here's more:
Bright and open Chilmark split-level home perfect for your next family vacation. FULLY AIR CONDITIONED. New refrigerator and commercial washing machine perfect for long stays. Fresh exterior paint and newly rebuilt wrap-around deck. Some interior upgrades expected by spring 2025. Wrap-around deck perfect for early morning reading, evening cocktails or star-gazing. Close to Alley's General Store, West Tisbury Farmer's Market, hiking trails and bike paths. Guests may purchase guest passes to Lucy Vincent Beach through Town of Chilmark. Walking access to nearby private Chilmark beach. Ten minute drive to Menemsha sunsets and lobsters or juicy whole belly fried clams at the Fish House in Edgartown-best take-out option for quick up-island dinners.
Amenities at Best Deal in Chilmark Spring Fling: Book May or June for 10% off. 4-day minimum.
Non-smoking
No pets allowed
Map of Menemsha, MA
Ratings and reviews
10 / 10Outstanding·Sep 2025
Excellent stay. Great host.
8 / 10Excellent·Jun 2025
Great stay in a beutifull island
10 / 10Outstanding·Dec 2023
My family and I absolutely loved our stay in this beautiful home in quiet Chilmark. The bucolic grounds were lush, green, and peaceful with cute natural neighbors (rabbits, which delighted my young children). We rode our bikes to the beach which was a highlight of our stay. The wrap-around deck with lounge chairs on one side and a large table with patio chairs and an umbrella on the other. There was also a grill that we didn't end up using but was great to have as an option. The open kitchen had plenty of utensils and a dishwasher. The dining room table was large with drawers that held lobster forks. I cannot stop raving about this amazing home, location and wonderful host. Thank you for an amazing 3 weeks!
6 / 10Average·Jun 2024
I have to admit this was a good deal for the Vineyard, but overall it wasn't a good experience. When we showed up everything was off or unplugged including the refrigerator. The basement was extremely musty, so we turned the dehumidifier on, which made it very hot. Then, we tried the brand new AC system and it wouldn't cool. I let the host know and she gave me instructions. It still wasn't working so she said she would contact a HVAC company, but I never heard back. It was very hot while there, and very uncomfortable.
The house itself is very private and a good size, but it definitely needs more TLC. There were updates made over the years, but it needs more love.
Pros: Private location, good size home. Access to private beach.
Cons: AC not working. Needs TLC. There were ants everywhere (which has been a universal problem this year due to rain).
$$$$
Top rated by guests
9.6Outstanding
(22 Ratings)
"Excellent stay. Great host."
Ted S.Don't miss out! Price and availability may change
